Hotels near Commodore Barry Park

"We felt safe here. We start here every time we visit NYC and probably always will."

"It’s ok"

"as always, Marriott showers smell like mildew. I have to say the staff at this property went above and beyond with any question, request or attitude. It was really amazing to see such great customer service within New York City. Please extend my thank you to everyone who covered the front desk, concierge, security, and the conference that was going on. If we can just get rid of the smell in the bath tubs or shower curtains, which I have come accustomed to at Marriott’s, my review would be so much better."

"Good overall"

"Great room and space was fine - was thinking room would be smaller! Coffee maker was a bonus. Staff at desk were always lovely and friendly. Mostly fine for waiting for lifts/elevators but at busier times was a longer wait. There are 3 though so wasn’t too bad as other reviews worried me about this before going. Room was clean and bed comfortable. Had to ask for firmer pillow though - they accommodated quickly. Walls are thin and did shake when other doors slammed shut. Situated by lift which wasn’t an issue but also by the cleaning cupboard so was woken a few times - one at 2:30am with someone on their walkie talkie. Smoke alarm was going off on night we got back - they removed battery and said would replace next day but it never got replaced before we then left. Overall a great stay - location is fab next to a lot of things and also to lots of subway options. Walkable to Staten Island ferry / charging bull / Wall Street etc. Would definitely stay here again."

"The heater in my room didn’t work and it’s was super loud when it was on blowing cold air. "

"Didn’t feel like a safe place, room also rented by the hour. There was shouting at night a large amount of noise from outside. Would not recommend."

"Yes and accommodating"

"No amenities and rooms are small but very clean."