Hotels in The Heights, Shelter Island Heights

"We were unhappy with two aspects. The shower is extremely small -- about 2 feet by 3 feet. Very tight. I personally would rip out the closet next to it in a heartbeat and enlarge the shower. The TV was also difficult to figure out and the staff on duty at the desk was unable to assist. Breakfast was fine, just monotonous -- it was always bagels, which isn't great with no toaster to toast them in."

"Really enjoyed our stay at the soundview. You are able to easily hear neighbors so just an FYI. Love being so close to the water and hearing the water and waves at night. Overnight oats at breakfast were my favorite. "

"This is one of the best hotels I have ever stayed at. The staff is gracious and very helpful, the property is spectacular and the rooms are unique. The consierge called ahead of our stay to ensure we had everything we needed. The food at the restaurant was very good. It’s a bit pricey, but well worth it. Attention to detail is a lost art, but not at this hotel! The valet service was especially good, helping with luggage and my husband’s wheelchair. We will surely return!"

"My room was no where near clean. Not only was there multiple urine stains on the toilet seat, there was also a fecal stain that was also not cleaned IN the toilet. How do you not clean the TOILET? "

"Clean room, nice breakfast options."

"Loved the place, clean and helpfull staff."

"Simply delightful!"

"Wonderful! What a beautiful property, room and the location is perfection!"

"Perfect hotel: nice huge bedroom, clean, microwave, fridge, nice location and great staff."