Search Cottages in Long Island

"We had a lovely stay and the staff were incredibly nice. The Fireside Inn was clean but not updated. We love that we had a little patio that we could run out to the car if we needed something instead of having to walk back to the front desk each time. We also loved the animal towel display on our bed (so fun!) and grab-and-go options for breakfast. We hope to stay here again in the future."

"Hotel itself was great. Very comfortable bed. Real nice room for the price. Breakfast was good too."

"We only stayed one night but were very impressed . The room we stayed in (47) was in the back building but had a cute little terrace and a nice view of the water. The staff were friendly and helpful, our room was impeccably clean and the shower had great water pressure and heat. We will definitely stay again next time we’re in the area!"

"Great for the price and location!"

"It was very convenient to highway. "

"It was an amazing day. The staff is super helpful and super polite."

"We stayed after a concert and it was great for the night. The bed was comfy, room was clean, had some drinks and snacks to choose from at the front. They offered breakfast in the morning, but we didn’t try it. I would stay again. "

"Good location. Palmer needs a lot of attention. Great staff. "

"Great staff, good location… our dogs loved the grounds "