Hotels near Pigeon Key

"The resort is very relaxing and beautiful. The welcome mojito set the vibe. We traveled with our 10 month old infant who had a wonderful time in the pool and beach. The rooms were large and clean. Requested a first floor patio and was assigned one. It really helped not having to do an elevator with our stroller, and having easy access to the pool "

"Super cute room! Comfortable bed and nice shower"

"Great for a long weekend. ++ amazing staff, get a massage from José, beachfront room was the best, Dry Rocks has a great vibe. Also, it's very family friendly. You can determine your preference there. Negative: valet only parking (is new) so if someone is just there for dinner, or salon services, or visiting, they are forced to pay $35 to park. Seems petty. This policy should be reconsidered especially for locals and diners. "

"The room was fantastic! Great view of the cove. The staff was great. Very clean and friendly "

"Love this place "

"Great stay!"

"Island Bay is the perfect tropical getaway. It only has 10 rooms, but they are spectacular cottages. The grounds and indoor decor are impeccable. The sunsets are unmatched. The adults-only, gated property was peaceful, and a joy to kick back in. Also, plenty of opportunity to fish, snorkel, or kayak."

"While the room looked "tired" (furniture was old and a little beat up). Room was mostly clean but could have been cleaner (ie: bottom of microwave had egg all over it from previous tenant, Closet floors didn't look like they have been mopped) but rest of it was really clean. Overall the resort was amazing! Nice pool, hot tub, and beach area. Beautiful sunsets! We unfortunately didn't get to try the restaurant as we ran out of time but people said it was good. "

"Everything was fine except half way through the stay the water department came and shut off the water at the street. It came back on a few hours later, so it all worked out. The house was fine"