Carlstadt Hotels with Swimming Pool

"I stayed here bc I was in town to see Gaga across the street at msg. The bed and pillows were comfy. But the cons are you can hear everything the next door people are doing, the shower head was shooting out water, the room/ bathroom way too small. They were also doing construction super early in the morning that I couldn't go back to sleep and my stomach was hurting. Also the bathroom bar soap was super thin. Other than that I enjoyed my view of the city and exploring it. Id stay here again if I ever attended a show at msg again. The front desk staff was very kind and the tick tock restaurant serves good food."

"Room was clean, just a little bit too loud ( some Other guests)"

"The air conditioning did not work at all. It was boiling hot in our room the entire time. The shower was nothing more than a trickle and it did not drain. "

"Great location. Friendly staff."

"Air conditioning was very effective but very loud"

"The room was very clean and comfortable. "

"Noisy neighbourhood Bad listeners- they charged my stay on the wrong credit card despite me warning them They charge for keeping your luggage in the locker room. Other hotels don’t "

"All good"

"This is a comfortable and accommodating luxurious hotel ideally situated for us across the street from St. Patrick Cathedral and within walking distance of great restaurants and Broadway shows. We will return here on our next visit to NYC."