Hotels in Menantic Creek, Shelter Island

"Tara was wonderful and helpful at check-in, the cleaning staff was so nice and thorough, and the food at Nookies and the Boathouse were both amazing!! "

"Lovely place for a quiet getaway off-season. Loved this place and will be back. Only disappointment was morning coffee … lacking flavor and lukewarm … but there is a wonderful shop just a few doors down with very good coffee. Nespresso machine in room. "

"Front desk staff were amazing! The bar staff were very attentive and friendly. Rooms are clean, but definitely dated."

"Incredible room"

"Clean, friendly and accessible."

"Loved our stay. Our room was gorgeous a s in the perfect location. Would recommend and plan on coming back in the future!"

"Parking easy"

"Overall our stay was a positive experience. It definitely is pretty outdated and common areas could use some maintenance (like peeling wallpaper and stained ceiling tiles) but everything was very clean, and I have high standards for cleanliness. The pool was very clean as well. We used it twice during our stay. Its a heated pool but don't expect bath water warm. Its just not freezing. Our room was nothing special but the bed was very comfortable. The bathroom is tiny but the photos arent misleading. The shower gets warm not hot. Not an issue for me but for others it might be. My only real complaint about the room was that we had planned to use the pullout couch for our daughter to sleep on but the mattress was extremely old, stained, and ripped. We assumed there would be sheets and a pillow for it but we had to call the desk and ask for it. Would have made more sense for the staff to ask at check in if we needed those things if they arent provided. Once we recieved those items we realized the sheet was much too big for that mattress. Kinda seemed like the pullout couch was not an actual option for a guest to use and we would not book that room again for that reason. The hotel is also right next to the highway and the windows are not well insulated so you hear the traffic at all times of day. Not an issue for my family but worth mentioning in a review. All the staff we had interactions with were super friendly. Would recommend as a budget friendly option in the area!"

"Everything was excellent about this property"