Hotels in Coecles Harbor, Shelter Island

"The check-in staff were friendly and helpful, finding us a different room when ours wasn’t available. The breakfast was significantly better than a simple continental, offering a variety of items. It is a sprawling complex on the LI sound, with nice views from our room and the dining areas. The restaurant, although a bit pricey, had great service, wonderful views, and excellent quality."

"Convenient location for an affordable price "

"pleasant visit staff very friendly "

"We had a lovely long weekend stay at this property at the end of March 2025. Our room was a very spacious efficiency. The wifi was good. There was plenty of parking available. We enjoyed being able to walk to nearby restaurants or go to the boardwalk. There is laundry available. There is no fitness area. Highly recommend."

"Simple and very easy check-in. In fact, we got our room about 2 hours early. The staff were very helpful. Room was as described. Well appointed and we appreciated the balcony looking out to the marina. Quiet and comfortable. The continental breakfast was okay. It was as advertised but, not like a breakfast at one of the hotel chains with any eggs, bacon, sausage, waffles, etc.. It had coffee and a no-caffine tea which was a plus, as well as fruit (fresh blueberries), bagels, muffins, yogurt, several cereals and juice. Checkout was very easy and we were even asked if we needed help with our bags. I would highly recommend the Sag Harbor Inn. Great place, great people and a great value. "

"Really nice property!"

"The hotel is clean"

"Yes"

"Everything was super clean and staff was friendly and helpful. "