Windley Key hotels from RM560

"The rooms were large and clean. The pillows were not great, they definitely need a comfort upgrade. The food on property was good. The breakfast was great! Lots of kids everywhere which made it hard to enjoy the pool. The beach was great and the bay was so nice. The majority of the staff was really nice. Ensure to check which package you booked with the front desk as they were hesitant to give us the breakfast package we paid for. I had to verify my package with them by showing them my trip confirmation email and they had to take a picture of my email for proof. Overall, it was a nice place to stay. "

"While this property was adequate, there were a number of annoyances we encountered in our 5 night stay. The toilet was clogged upon our arrival. Maintenance guy pulled out a bar of soap. Very embarrassing for my partner who had used the toilet and couldn't flush it. Ants on the counter and table. The staff came and sprayed Raid on the counter and said an exterminator would be there the next day. The film of Raid remained so we couldnt use the counter until housekeeping cleaned it. I asked for NO housekeeping upon our arrival but someone was in the room at least twice and didnt actually clean it but left a few toiletries, took 2 towels, but left the others. AC unit was working but cycled on and off all night which is not great for a light sleeper. On the positive side, they offered free kayaks but it was difficult to arrange for one because the staff weren't sure when they were available. Even though 5 kayaks were sitting on the beach seemingly unused, the staff said that they were being used by someone. 10 minutes later, all of the kayaks were available even though none had moved. The staff was pleasant and friendly but i got tired of asking for situations to be resolved so i gave up and made do. Everyone is expensive in the Keys so the price was OK...$1227 for 2 people for 5 nights. Good parking. Ice machine was free. Laundry machines were available..around $2 to wash and $2.50 to dry but we didnt use them. The beach is OK, grassy bottom, rough sand and 3 docks.Comfy beds"

"Worst breakfast ever! Everything thing else great!"

"Yes very convenient to excursions. Breakfast was good. Expensive for just cereal and fruit."

"It was okay "

"This property is in a perfect location for walking to restaurants and bars. They have 2 very nice pools to choose from. The canal view room we had was very spacious and the balcony was very large to watch boats and nature pass by. The room fridge/freezer was just about full size which made it nice to keep leftovers and lots of drinks. Air conditioning was perfect temp and parking is included in your stay and ample. We also got to use the sister property's amenities which is called The Islander. All of the staff were very friendly and helpful. Jass the manager is wonderful! We will be back next season with our whole family! Thank you for a very memorable stay!"

"This was absolutely horrible! Amara Cay overbooked us, tried to blame Expedia, ruined our trip and moved us to their sister site even though our friends were staying there. "

"We had a great stay. Highly recommended!"

"Loved the location. View from our room was beautiful. We also loved Alfie at the front desk. She was a sweetheart. So helpful and wonderful personality. Great asset to the resort. We will definitely return. "