Hotels near Shelter Island

"Room is clean and services are great"

"Staff was friendly, room was clean and comfortable, loved having a balcony, walkable to the harbor with restaurants and a grocery store."

"The location is gorgeous, it was close to everything such as restaurants, theme parks, and beautiful beaches. Our room was clean and functional. We had a magnificent view of the docked boats. The most impressive part was the staff members were extremely polite and accommodating."

"There were no beddings for the sofa bed, so i asked for them but we got it after few hours later after midnight after the several reminders. I got charged for the parking fee $25/day even though we didn't even have a car, so i requested a refund."

"Clean and efficient. My dog got a good night sleep."

"nice room , amazing view . the pool and hot tub were not busy and nice"

"This hotel was wonderful, but what made it really outstanding was the staff! From the shuttle driver to the front desk ladies to the cleaning crew, everyone was polite, respectful, and welcoming. If we return, it will be because of them! The breakfast was delicious. The location is convenient and the property is beautiful. "

"We just stayed one night, love the waffles! "

"Small room"