Shelter Island Heights Guest Houses

Check prices for these dates

Next weekend

In two weeks

In one month

In two months

Our top choices for Shelter Island Heights guest houses

House on Chase Creek

The Heights

Robert

RM1,280 total

includes taxes & fees

16 Jun - 17 Jun

Hampton's Vacation Inn

Hampton Bays

Iris

RM1,231 total

includes taxes & fees

23 Jun - 24 Jun

View all properties

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Sign in

Sign up, it's free

Top Shelter Island Heights Hotel Reviews

Aqualina Inn Montauk

10/10 Excellent

"Hotel and room were very clean. Perfect location walking distance into town. Check in was easy and front desk manager was very nice and courteous. We will be back!"

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

2/10 Terrible

"For a property charging roughly $1,500 per night, this was one of the most disappointing hotel experiences I’ve had. The issue started when I found bugs in my room. I called the front desk to ask if they had any mosquito or bug spray available and was told they did not. When I explained that there were bugs in the room, I was then asked where the bug was and whether I could point it out. The interaction felt less like they were trying to help and more like I was being asked to prove that the bug existed. Bugs move, and it’s not always possible to immediately locate one again after you’ve seen it. Eventually, someone was sent to the room with a spray bottle. However, the bottle appeared to contain some type of cleaning solution rather than an actual insect treatment. It had a strong chemical smell and left the room smelling unpleasant afterward. At no point was I given confidence that the underlying issue was actually being addressed. That night, I was woken up by a bug in my bed. I reached down because my arm felt itchy and ended up touching the bug, which startled me awake. I barely slept the rest of the night. What frustrates me most is not even the bug itself. Hotels near the beach can occasionally have insects. The real issue was the response. Instead of taking a guest’s concern seriously and working to resolve it, I felt dismissed from the beginning. The handling of the situation felt unprofessional and, frankly, insulting."

Water's Edge Resort & Spa

8/10 Good

"The resort was very nice and well maintained. I would say the staff wasn't that great. I've much better experiences. I enjoyed my massage and spa. The only complaint I have is that at a room near mine room was very loud and woke me up at 11:30. I couldn't get a response from dialing 0 and I tried 5x. When I brought it to the attention of the front desk clerk she really didn't seem to care much."

Beachcomber Resort at Montauk

6/10 Okay

"This was our second visit. This unit was very dated, dull and unattractive. The room had a few issues, lightbulbs, a stuck door, the pullout sofa needed bedding. But each was addressed and fixed within minutes. The staff was great. I will say the mattress was like sleeping on a cloud. The grounds are beautiful and we enjoyed the pool which is heated to 85^"

Kenny's Tipperary Inn

10/10 Excellent

"We love staying at Kenny’s. They have several relaxing lounge areas: pool area, lounge area outside of the pool, and the zen garden. The apartment rooms are great and have a full kitchen. Kenny’s offers a beach pass that gives you access to all local beaches. And the hotel is very close to Gosman’s dock and other restaurants. We’ll definitely be back!"

Find out more about Shelter Island Heights