Most Romantic Hotels in Fire Island

"It was the perfect location for my one night stay. The hotel is lovely, if the room a little dated. The staff was friendly and kind. And if took less than 15 minutes to get to the office. "

"This was a super friendly place to stay. Very clean and felt very safe there. "

"I have been to a lot of hotels in LI but this one stands out. Staff is very pleasant and accommodating. From restaurant staff to front desk everyone was very friendly. They gave us late check out. They also do daily room service without asking which after Covid hotels have stopped doing which is another plus. Pool is on the smaller side but isn’t very busy so can accommodate. Overall great experience. Will be returning and strongly recommend. "

"It was a quick stay but very quick and easy check in, room was ready immediately and everything was clean. "

"it was good"