We stayed at 3 hotels on Bantayan: Hoyohoy, Anika, and Coral Blue. Of the 3, we preferred Hoyohoy. It was the cleanest, and had the most relaxing atmosphere. The grounds are quite pretty, tucked far from the main road, with green landscaping, and an oceanside setting. Of, course, it is very near to the pier, which makes swimming undesirable and the beach less attractive. Also, the "swimming pool" at Hoyohoy is more like a green pond with moss. This hotel should not be allowed to claim it has a pool. Another drawback was the breakfast, which, although served in nice presentation, was ridiculously overpriced, (most expensive of any hotel we saw) and not great. However, with that said, the room (an upper unit) was lovely, with vaulted ceilings, windows all around, and a comfortable bed. The bathroom was exceptionally clean and spacious, with a bathtub and an interesting outdoor shower. The staff were nice enough to allow us early check-in, but overall not particularly welcoming or friendly. Still, that seems to be the case all over the island. Bantayan has lower standards and less tourist infrastructure than some other Philippines destinations. Still, overall, we thought this was a pretty and pleasant hotel. With a little more attention to detail and a few improvements, it could amazing.