Hotels near Rodman's Hollow

"Everything is always excellent here. The rooms are always well stocked without being overstocked; you have the ability for physical and downloadable media to watch and enjoy; parking passes are always supplied without having to ask for them; wake up calls are attentive and they don't forget them; and, I'm writing this review as a person who has been to Montauk Manor on 11 different occasions. I love what they have done with their exercise room and the changes they made to their pool and sauna area - and believe you me, I used every amenity available to me. Also, the restaurant is phenomenal - I actually went to it when it first opened back up, and it continues to not disappoint! If you are looking for a One-Stop shop, a place where you can just sit and be, a place where you can be within walking or short driving or biking distance to montauk, the beach, the lighthouse or a short excursion to wineries and such, this is the place for you. As a matter of fact, I am already planning my 13th visit!"

"Accommodations were clean and well equipped, well worth the price!"

"Ok"

"Very friendly staff and easy check-in. Room was clean."

"Upon arrival, the gentleman who greeted us was extemly nice and professional. However, he didnt know wich room or area we were staying in. He asked if we were staying in the Farm house we said yes. He then began to ask if we were sure we wanted to stay in that room since it was two bedrooms and there was only two of us. (Absolutely this is what we paid for.) He took us to the farm suite wich i thought was very nice. Until he opened the door and there was another guests stuff in the room. He apologized, we all had a laugh, and then i pulled up my reservation and confirmed it was the apartment not the suite. He drove us back to the lobby to get the farm house suite key. I was willing to let that go, this morning we were trying to catch the 11:00am ferry. We stoped in the lobby to return our key and grab breakfast wich is listed from 8am-11am. We walked in at 10:20 asked the person cleaning the tables if we could grab some breakfast and were told no, its too late. So to be honest, this "resort" has no real food on site, they do 30-45 minutes of "champagn and nibble" in the evening, and breakfast for 2 hours at 8am. Note to the owner: Subpar experience for $500 a night."

"Stayed here one night while passing through. Room was smaller than I expected (patio king). I also assumed the patio was attached to the room but it was not. Room floor was dirty (sand, etc.) otherwise room was clean. Our coffee pot didn’t work. There was a $50 dog fee upon check in that wasn’t listed at time of booking online so that was a surprise. Staff were super friendly and happy to see our dogs. We did receive a doggy gift bag at check in. Hotel was in a great location. Restaurant attached to hotel was nice as well."

"Room was clean, walking distance to nice restaurant. Ocean view. NO elevator for upper floor rooms."

"Hotel was great! We enjoyed the pool, sauna and appy hour! Breakfast was nice too. "

"The Montauk Yacht Club is a beautiful and relaxing getaway with a true coastal luxury feel. The property is well-maintained, with scenic waterfront views that make the entire experience feel special and refreshing. The rooms are comfortable and thoughtfully designed, offering a clean and modern aesthetic. The Service is generally attentive, and the overall vibe is calm yet upscale without feeling overly formal. It’s a great place for a weekend escape or a special occasion, especially if you enjoy being near the water. Overall: A stylish, peaceful retreat with a strong vacation vibe."