Hotels near Old Hay Bay Church National Historic Site

"Not bad but not great. Overall it seems like the hotel facilities are too small for the number of rooms. The eating area, pool and hot tub are all pretty small and busy. And the sound proofing sucks. Felt like I could hear every door shut in the hotel. "

"Always appreciate the hotel breakfast. "

"Great little place "

"FILTHY DISGUSTING The room was filthy on arrival: the bathroom had marks on the walls resembling dried bodily fluids and feces, silverfish in the shower, a grime-caked showerhead, and a dirty floor. The bed linens were stained and visibly dirty. The television flickered constantly, the remote didn’t work even with new batteries, HDMI and USB ports were broken, and the lamps flickered or turned off. Housekeeping did not refresh the room during our multi-day stay, and when we requested towels and cups, staff were rude and refused service. The pool was unusable due to dangerously high chlorine levels, which burned our eyes and left our vision cloudy. The only positive interaction was with one older staff member at check-in; every other employee was rude, dismissive, and unprofessional, particularly a blonde front desk worker who snapped at both guests and coworkers. Parking was poorly managed, and staff were unhelpful when we had to use a non-designated spot. Overall, the level of cleanliness, maintenance, and customer service was shocking and far below any reasonable standard. This hotel failed in every basic aspect, and I cannot recommend it to anyone. Immediate action is needed to prevent future guests from experiencing this unacceptable level of neglect."

"Clean, beautiful and friendly hotel in a serene and relaxing setting. Delicious restaurant. Allows pets. I’m so happy I stayed here and would highly recommend."

"The room was large and everything was nicely put together. We got a greag upgrade due to issues with our original room. The upgrade was fantastic and greatly appreciated. "

"It was quaint and quiet at this time of year. A nice little getaway from the city. Beautiful view of the lake and beach from our Lodge. "

"Quaint hotel next to the water. Really beautiful area behind the hotel with chairs. Extremely friendly staff. Free parking. The Lighthouse restaurant was just inside and was excellent. The rooms were small but comfortable. The sheets on the beds were so amazingly soft. "

"Very clean room. Parking was easy. Great central location and walking distance to shops, restaurants, etc. "