Caldwell Vacation Rentals

"Overall good hotel and would book again. We had a king bedroom with an adjoining room with two queens. Bathrooms were tiny. The shower didn’t have a sliding door, and the bathrooms had no locks. Tiny closet and no dresser. Had to live all week out of suitcase. Also no fridge. Can’t beat the location though! Steps away from Times Square and Broadway shows. The meal vouchers were nice. Three options to use them. The best free breakfast was the one outside the hotel just steps away down the block. Clean nice hotel. Nice staff. Felt secure too, with someone watching the elevators to make sure only guests with keycards accessed the elevators."

"Everyone knows that NYC Hotel rooms are overpriced and small. But I was pleasantly surprised by the size and “affordability” of this room…Up to date, beds were good, bath was good- can’t say anything bad about the room or hotel. Perfect stay! Would recommend!"

"Room was clean but shower was terrible, draining issues( were sorted next day up to a limit), using shower was tricky, all three the tap, hand held shower and rain shower work together or only hand held, we found setting pretty unfriendly. For Brits: no tea facilities in the room. Staff was good, a separate fridge was provided so if you don’t want to use mini bar then still have a chance to keep your drinks nice and cooler."

"Great staff. Clean room with tv, a bed, a closet, a chair, a bathtub - a great price but few amenities. I had to ask for paper cups ( no glasses) or coffee or chargers. The lobby was striking art deco and there was a café in the hotel where you could get coffee. Also a great location if you want to enjoy Broadway shows and Times Square."

"Great"

"We recently stayed at The New Yorker for a quick two-day, one-night trip, and overall had a pleasant experience. The hotel itself is nice and centrally located right off 8th Avenue, making it very convenient for exploring the heart of New York. Although there was construction happening outside, it did not impact our stay. Check-in was a highlight. The front desk associate was welcoming, allowed us an early check-in, and even provided an upgraded room, which we truly appreciated. There were a few small touches that could have made the stay even better. For a hotel of this size and location, it would have been nice to have complimentary coffee or water available in the lobby. While the room included a Keurig, it only had coffee and no tea options. Additionally, there was no microwave in the room or accessible anywhere in the hotel. After ordering in-room dining, which was quite expensive, it would have been helpful to reheat leftovers rather than having to go back out. Bathroom amenities were also very basic. Items like lotion or makeup remover wipes would have been a nice addition, especially compared to other hotels at a similar or even lower price point. Overall, we enjoyed our stay, especially the location and customer service, but a few added conveniences and amenities would elevate the experience even more. "

"It was a NYC hotel room. Very small but good quality."

"Best part of this place is the location. Room was okay. Little dirty in the corners. But bedding was crisp and clean. Staff made our beds daily and was friendly. Descent value for the hustle and bustle of NYC."

"Staff was nice and very polite perfect hospitality,I had a standard king for one night basic room decent space ok bed perfect shower pressure and it's in the middle of all the action def worth a stay"